Cover photo for Gary J. KINNICUTT's Obituary


December 19, 1949 — October 30, 2020

Gary J. KINNICUTT, Sr., 70, of Scio, NY, died Friday, October 30, 2020 in his home.

Born December 19, 1949, in Wellsville, he was the son of Donald and Cora Jackson Kinnicutt.  On March 9, 1975, in Wellsville, he married the former Jody L. Metcalf, who predeceased him on June 10, 2009.

A graduate of Friendship High School, he was employed by Alstom as a mobile crane operator and welder for many years.  Gary loved to hunt, fish, target shoot with the grandkids, and take care of his yard.

Surviving are:  three children, Gary (Hillary) Kinnicutt, Jr. of Tiona, PA, Christie (Donald) Baker of Andover, and Matthew (Tammy) Kinnicutt of Scio;  ten grandchildren, Makala Kinnicutt, Kira Kinnicutt, Kaleigh Kinnicutt, Zachary Crisman, Shelbie Crisman, TJ Crisman, Alexander Baker, Rees Baker, Preston Kinnicutt, and Chase Kinnicutt;  three brothers, George (Brenda) Kinnicutt of Suisun, CA, David Kinnicutt of Wellsville, and Kenneth (Marianne) Harris of Wellsville;  a sister, Linda Maxwell of Wellsville;  nieces and nephews.  In addition to his parents and his wife, he was predeceased by two brothers, Ronald Kinnicutt and Terry Kinnicutt.

Cremation was at Olney-Foust Crematory.  Burial will be in Knights Creek Cemetery, Scio.

Memorials may be made to St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital at or the National Kidney Foundation at

Arrangements are entrusted to Mulholland-Crowell Funeral Home, Wellsville, NY.  Online condolences may be expressed at

To send flowers to the family in memory of Gary J. KINNICUTT, please visit our flower store.


Visits: 53

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors